British Courts Not Supporting British Design
(Dyson Ltd v Vax Ltd – 2011)
“What really matters is what the court can see with its own eyes”
- Sir Robin Jacob , Dyson Ltd v Vax Ltd  EWCA Civ 1206, 27 October 2011
The Court of Appeal has upheld an earlier High Court decision in Dyson v Vax. It agreed that Vax had not infringed Dyson’s intellectual property by designing and producing the Mach Zen vacuum cleaner. Although it looked quite similar the court concluded that it “produced a different overall impression on the informed user” (this being the test for infringement) and was therefore not in breach.
Why is this decision important? Like all registered design owners Dyson has the exclusive right to use its registered design for a maximum of 25 years following registration. Dyson registered the design in 1994 so had thought that no competitors would be able to make a similar looking and functioning vacuum cleaner until at least 2019. What this decision has shown, however, is that simply registering the overall design of a product is no longer enough. Such a broad registration will not give sufficient protection to those aspects of a product that really do require safeguarding. Although the products were clearly similar in function and design the court concluded that “what really matters is what the court can see with its own eyes”, and in this instance it saw too many differences. Overall, the appeal judges characterized the registered design as producing a visual impression that is “smooth, curving and elegant” whilst that of the Mach Zen is “rugged, angular and industrial”. This, it concluded, gave a “different overall impression on the informed user”.
Myers Lister Price Corporate and Commercial Department: Intellectual Property, offer a full registered design service, from advising on the strengths of a registered design application, through the registration itself and onto protection of the design and enforcement of the intellectual property rights. As we have learnt from the Dyson case, simply registering an overall design of a product may no longer be enough to protect the product from being copied. We would advise our clients (as the UK and EU laws allow) to not only protect the design of a whole product but to also consider protecting specific parts of a product. Our experienced intellectual property team are on hand to advise what aspects of a design may be worth protecting and how this can best be done for you.
If you have any intellectual property enquiries please get in touch with Stephen Attree or Awena Parry, our Intellectual Property Solicitors at Myers Lister Price Solicitors on 0845 0738 445 or email firstname.lastname@example.org
Latest MLP Solicitors News
- July 29th, 2014Shared Parental Leave Regulations and more in our Employment Law update
It’s time for MLP’s quick round up of the key talking points in employment law for the week ending 25 July 2014.
NewsDraft shared parental leave regulations laid before … Read more
- July 21st, 2014Does obesity qualify as a disability? Employment Law news round up…
It’s time for MLP’s quick round up of the key talking points in employment law for the week ending 18 July 2014. Employment law news:
Does obesity qualify as … Read more
- July 15th, 2014Employment law update July 2014
It’s time for MLP’s quick round up of the key talking points in employment law at the moment. It’s a bumper edition as we cover employment law news from … Read more
- July 10th, 2014The Law Society setup a joint venture company with Mastek UK LTD
- July 7th, 2014Restructure to encourage buyers
Planning to sell your business? Since the business landscape has improved, we’ve noticed an increase in prospective buyers who are in the market for good assets. Buyers are still much … Read more
- July 7th, 2014Child Support Agency – Parents to be charged to use the collection services
- July 3rd, 2014Credit control – making it pay
All businesses experience good and bad periods during their lifetime. However, it is when cash flow slows, that businesses fail. The late payment, or non-payment, of invoices/bills can have a … Read more
- July 2nd, 2014How to settle a commercial dispute
Why would you want to settle a dispute? A settlement presents a business with certainty, closure and avoids the anxiety, costs and time of proceeding to trial. It can be … Read more
- July 1st, 2014What does the Consumer Rights Directive mean?
The 2013 Regulations implement the Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU) to ensure the harmonisation of distance selling and off-premises rules across EU member states. What and who do the … Read more
- July 1st, 2014Zero hours contracts and other employment headlines
It’s time for MLP’s quick round up of the key talking points in employment law for the week ending 27 June 2014. Employment law news Government to ban “exclusivity … Read more
- July 1st, 2014Delays in Lasting Power of Attorney Applications
All Lasting Powers of Attorney (LPAs) must be registered with the Office of the Public Guardian (OPG) before they can be used by the attorney. The application for registration can … Read more
- July 1st, 2014HMRC launches new consultation on taxing trusts
- June 30th, 2014Right to request Flexible Working extended to all employees
From 30 June 2014, the right to request flexible working is open to all employees with at least 26 weeks’ continuous service. Previously, this right was only available to employees … Read more
- June 27th, 2014Biting back! Could Liverpool sack Luis Suarez for gross misconduct?!
As World Cup Fever continues to grip the nation (even despite another humiliating display by England!) it seems that everyone is talking about it. Football’s governing body, FIFA, also spent … Read more
- June 17th, 2014How to protect your business brand
A big part of managing your company’s reputation is based on protecting your brand, particularly in highly competitive markets. So, what is a brand and what practical steps help a … Read more
- June 16th, 2014Deceased workers entitled to holiday pay…and other employment news
It’s time for MLP’s quick round up of the key talking points in employment law form last week. Employment law news World Cup 2014 finally arrives: The World Cup is … Read more
- June 16th, 20145 alternative funding routes for SMEs
- June 13th, 2014What to do when a beneficiary of an estate is missing
If you are appointed as the executor of an estate, you have a duty to make sure that it is distributed to the correct people – the ‘beneficiaries’. This can … Read more
- June 10th, 2014Top tips for employers around World Cup 2014
It’s been 4 long years but it’s finally arrived! World Cup 2014 is almost upon us! However, just like they did prior to London 2012, employers are bracing themselves for … Read more
- June 9th, 20148 pitfalls to avoid when negotiating contracts
Contract negotiations can be a minefield, so we thought it would be helpful to highlight the top eight pitfalls that are avoidable during the process. 1. Does the person … Read more
- June 9th, 2014The Queen’s Speech and how it affects workers
It’s time for MLP’s quick round up of the key talking points in employment law for the week ending 6 June 2014. Employment law in the news Queen’s Speech 2014 … Read more