British Courts Not Supporting British Design
(Dyson Ltd v Vax Ltd – 2011)
“What really matters is what the court can see with its own eyes”
- Sir Robin Jacob , Dyson Ltd v Vax Ltd  EWCA Civ 1206, 27 October 2011
The Court of Appeal has upheld an earlier High Court decision in Dyson v Vax. It agreed that Vax had not infringed Dyson’s intellectual property by designing and producing the Mach Zen vacuum cleaner. Although it looked quite similar the court concluded that it “produced a different overall impression on the informed user” (this being the test for infringement) and was therefore not in breach.
Why is this decision important? Like all registered design owners Dyson has the exclusive right to use its registered design for a maximum of 25 years following registration. Dyson registered the design in 1994 so had thought that no competitors would be able to make a similar looking and functioning vacuum cleaner until at least 2019. What this decision has shown, however, is that simply registering the overall design of a product is no longer enough. Such a broad registration will not give sufficient protection to those aspects of a product that really do require safeguarding. Although the products were clearly similar in function and design the court concluded that “what really matters is what the court can see with its own eyes”, and in this instance it saw too many differences. Overall, the appeal judges characterized the registered design as producing a visual impression that is “smooth, curving and elegant” whilst that of the Mach Zen is “rugged, angular and industrial”. This, it concluded, gave a “different overall impression on the informed user”.
Myers Lister Price Corporate and Commercial Department: Intellectual Property, offer a full registered design service, from advising on the strengths of a registered design application, through the registration itself and onto protection of the design and enforcement of the intellectual property rights. As we have learnt from the Dyson case, simply registering an overall design of a product may no longer be enough to protect the product from being copied. We would advise our clients (as the UK and EU laws allow) to not only protect the design of a whole product but to also consider protecting specific parts of a product. Our experienced intellectual property team are on hand to advise what aspects of a design may be worth protecting and how this can best be done for you.
If you have any intellectual property enquiries please get in touch with Stephen Attree or Awena Parry, our Intellectual Property Solicitors at Myers Lister Price Solicitors on 0845 0738 445 or email firstname.lastname@example.orgGoogle+
Latest MLP Solicitors News
- March 12th, 2014Is the world going crazy?
Probably, but let’s enjoy the ride to madness! I’m not going to use this blog to spout about the dumbing down of language – I actually think taking the jargon … Read more
- March 12th, 2014Family law – mediate, don’t litigate!
Family law continues to face many changes in the coming weeks and months. 22 April 2014 sees the launch of The Family Court, replacing the jurisdictions of the Family Proceedings … Read more
- March 12th, 2014What is the Government doing to tackle rogue landlords?
Last month the Government published its policy paper on the review of property conditions in the private rented sector. The discussion document essentially considers what more can be done to … Read more
- March 10th, 2014Why you should have a Lasting Power of Attorney
A woman who sold her elderly mother’s house without any formal authority to do so has been ordered to pay costs by the Court of Protection. This is something that … Read more
- March 7th, 2014Employment law round up
We want to keep all of our clients and contacts aware of changes in legislation or news that could affect them or their own clients in some way. So, here’s … Read more
- March 7th, 2014Mandatory Early Conciliation A Month Away
- March 3rd, 2014Sanctimonious Sanctions: Your Litigation Friend
- February 27th, 2014Going up – from Ghostbusters to growth forecasts
- February 24th, 2014What we’ve learned from Sochi 2014
- February 20th, 2014Spring in the air?
Apologies that my Wednesday blog is a little late this week. A burglary at home on Tuesday evening put me back somewhat. Still the wonders of modern technology means I … Read more
- February 12th, 2014Does your business need Director’s Service Agreements?
- February 12th, 2014Go big or go home!
- February 5th, 2014The future is online – so what are the risks?
I don’t do my Wednesday blog as often as I should (i.e. every Wednesday!) I will do my very best from now on. My 3 pointers for the week:… Read more
- February 3rd, 2014Wills valid despite wrong signature
Wills Valid Despite Error The Supreme Court ruled this week that a couple’s Wills should still stand, despite them signing the wrong ones. Alfred and Maureen Rawlings prepared mirror Wills … Read more
- January 29th, 2014What to expect in employment law in 2014
Another year, another round of employment law reform! But what are the changes we are expecting in 2014 and how might these affect your business? Amendments to TUPE and collective … Read more
- January 20th, 2014TUPE changes 2014
Changes to TUPE and collective redundancy rules – 31 January 2014 Tucked away in the haze of the New Year is the introduction of changes to TUPE 2006 and the … Read more
- January 15th, 2014How will HS2 affect my property value?
- January 9th, 2014Why Making a Will Should Be Your New Year’s Resolution
The start of a new year is often the time when we make resolutions and think more about the future. One of the most important parts of planning for the … Read more
- January 7th, 2014Is it worth putting a Shareholders’ Agreement in place?
The value of a Shareholders’ Agreement We often have to consider the value of a shareholders’ agreement when discussing planning with our clients. Why do you need one? Too often … Read more
- January 3rd, 2014Dare To Litigate?
Resolving non payment issues All businesses aim to build good relationships with customers and flexibility around chasing payment can sometimes be tempting when looking to establish favour. However, business is … Read more
- December 10th, 2013Poorly performing Doctor in your partnership?
Top tips for dealing with a poorly performing partner. How do you deal with a poorly performing partner? This is a question we have had to address a number of … Read more